Healthy Leaders part 1 – Good God

Am I doing enough?

Is this all going to go belly up?

If you lead anything — a team, a church, a household, a small group that meets in your front room on a Tuesday — you’ve asked some version of those two questions, probably more recently than you’d like to admit. I know I have. Plenty of leaders I coach and sit across from confess the same quiet undercurrent: a low hum of imposter syndrome, a sense that they’re one bad season away from being found out, a driven-ness that looks like passion from the outside but feels like proving from the inside.

Here’s what I’ve come to believe after years of watching leaders burn out, coast, or genuinely thrive: none of that gets fixed with a better strategy. It gets addressed at a much deeper level — the level of what you actually believe about God.

Everything Rises or Falls on …

Scripture puts something remarkable in front of leaders before it gives them any instructions about leading:

“Keep watch over yourselves and all the flock of which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers. Be shepherds of the church of God, which he bought with his own blood.” — Acts 20:28

Notice the order. Keep watch over yourselves. Not the flock first. You first. Because whatever is happening inside the shepherd will eventually show up in how the sheep are led.

And what’s happening inside so many of us — if we’re honest — is that we’re leading out of a low-grade fear rather than a settled revelation. Fear that we’re not enough. Fear that the whole thing depends on us performing flawlessly. Fear that if people really knew what was going on beneath the surface, they’d lose confidence in us entirely.

Without a clear revelation that God is good — that he is genuinely for you and genuinely with you — healthy leadership will always, eventually, elude you. You’ll drive yourself to prove your worth. You’ll overcome one insecurity only to discover another lurking behind it. You’ll do the maths on your own performance every single week, and the maths will never quite add up to peace.

Good

There’s a reason the word “good” appears so early and so often in Scripture’s own story of the world. Creation itself is called good — not merely acceptable, but good in the sense of everything working in line with its purpose, everything held together in harmony. That’s close to what the Hebrew word shalom actually means: not simply an absence of conflict, but peace, wholeness, prosperity, health — things fitting together as they were designed to.

When you carry a settled revelation that God is good, you’re not just affirming a nice theological idea. You’re anchoring your leadership in the conviction that the world — and your part in it — was built for flourishing, not for constant crisis management. That conviction changes how you interpret a hard week. It’s the difference between “everything is falling apart” and “we’re in a hard season, but there’s good ahead.”

The Spirit He Gave You

Paul writes to Timothy — a young, clearly anxious leader, if you read between the lines of those letters — with a sentence that deserves to be read slowly:

“For the Spirit God gave us does not make us timid, but gives us power, love and self-discipline.” — 2 Timothy 1:7

Timidity, in that verse, isn’t shyness. It’s the cowering, small, defensive posture of someone convinced they’re on their own, that everything depends on their own resources, that one mistake will unravel the whole project. Paul says plainly: that is not the spirit God gave you. What he gave you instead was power, love, and a sound mind. If you’re leading from fear, you’re leading from a spirit that was never actually issued to you.

That’s worth meditating on and praying about. The insecurity many of us carry isn’t a personality trait we’re stuck with. It’s a misunderstanding we’ve been leading from, sometimes for years, without ever noticing we had the option to put it down.

Even in Exile, Still Good

Here’s where the revelation gets tested, because it’s easy to believe God is good when the numbers are up and the team is thriving. It’s much harder to believe it in the seasons that feel like exile — the plateau, the setback, the leader who’s watching something they built quietly struggle.

God’s word to his people, sent into exile for seventy years, was not “abandon hope until things improve.” It was this:

“For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the Lord, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.” — Jeremiah 29:11

That promise was spoken into the hardest, most disorienting season those people would ever face. Not after it. During it. Which means the revelation that God is good isn’t reserved for the leaders whose graphs are trending upward. It’s available in the exile seasons too — arguably it’s needed there most.

David, who knew both the mountaintop and the wilderness better than most leaders ever will, arrived at the same settled place by the end of his life: “Surely your goodness and love will follow me all the days of my life, and I will dwell in the house of the Lord for ever.” (Psalm 23:6) Not “surely things will always go smoothly.” Surely his goodness will follow me. Every day. Whatever the day holds.

Why This Has to Come First

This is the hub the rest of your leadership turns on. Vision, strategy, team culture, systems — every single one of the practical things we’ll get into later in this series only functions well when it’s being driven by a leader who isn’t secretly performing for their own sense of worth. A leader convinced of God’s goodness can absorb criticism without collapsing. They can celebrate someone else’s success without feeling threatened by it. They can make a hard call without needing everyone in the room to validate it first.

A leader who is quietly unconvinced of God’s goodness will eventually turn every single one of those same situations into evidence for their own insecurity.

This Week

Ask yourself honestly: when things go wrong, what’s the first sentence that runs through your head? Is it some version of “I’ve failed” and “I’m not enough” — or is it “God is good?” You may not be able to change that instant reflex overnight. But you can start naming it, and you can start replacing it, deliberately, with the actual truth on offer in Jeremiah 29:11 and Psalm 23:6.

Healthy leadership doesn’t begin with a framework. It begins with a revelation. Before you lead anyone else this week, let that settle: God is good, he is for you, and he is with you — not because of what you’ve produced, but because that was always who he is.

Next in this series: once that foundation is settled, the next healthy habit is surprisingly countercultural — a genuinely healthy leader’s vision is narrower than you’d expect, not wider.

Enjoy This? Check out my new book SAINTS OUT NOW